Where did you first take communion?
Every Christian church takes the Lord’s Supper seriously. Where we differ is what happens with the bread and the cup. Tap a view to see the churches that hold it and what they believe.
A few groups, like many Quakers, don’t use outward bread and cup at all. They focus on inward, spiritual fellowship with Christ.
What was in the first Passover?
Exodus 12, on Israel’s last night in Egypt.
- Lamb or young goat Roasted whole, not boiled (Exodus 12:3–9).
- Bread without yeast No time for it to rise (Exodus 12:8, 39).
- Bitter herbs To remember how bitter slavery was (Exodus 12:8).
- Blood on the doorframe A sign, not a food. Judgment passed over the marked homes (Exodus 12:7, 13).
- Dressed to leave Belt on, sandals on, staff in hand, eating in a hurry (Exodus 12:11).
Exodus 12 doesn’t mention four cups, a Seder plate or a hidden piece of bread. Those came later as Jewish families kept retelling the story.
From Egypt to today
How the meal moved from a night in Egypt to our table.
- c. 1446 or c. 1260 BCThe first Passover
Israel’s last night in Egypt (Exodus 12). Scholars debate the date, so both common dates are shown.
- In the wildernessPassover kept on the road
Numbers 9 even makes room for people who were away or unclean to keep it a month later.
- In the landPassover at Gilgal
The first Passover in the promised land (Joshua 5:10–12). Later it moved to the place God chose (Deuteronomy 16).
- c. 715 and 622 BCKings bring it back
Hezekiah and Josiah lead huge national Passovers after years of neglect (2 Chronicles 30 and 35).
- c. AD 30–33The Last Supper
Jesus eats the Passover with His disciples, gives thanks and says, “Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22).
- c. AD 53–55Paul writes 1 Corinthians
He passes on Jesus’ words and corrects a church that was dividing at the table (1 Corinthians 11).
- AD 70The temple is destroyed
Lamb sacrifices end. Jewish Passover becomes a home meal built around retelling the story.
- c. AD 100The Didache
An early Christian handbook with prayers of thanks over the cup and bread.
- c. AD 150Justin Martyr
Describes Sunday worship: readings, prayers, bread and wine, deacons taking a portion to the absent.
- c. AD 200The Mishnah
Jewish writings describe four cups and questions at the Passover meal, the roots of today’s Seder.
- 1215Fourth Lateran Council
The Western church defines transubstantiation.
- 1529Marburg Colloquy
Luther and Zwingli meet and can’t agree on the Lord’s Supper. Protestants split into Lutheran and Reformed.
- 1551Council of Trent
The Catholic Church restates transubstantiation in response to the Reformers.
- 1869Grape juice
Thomas Welch, a Methodist communion steward, makes “Dr. Welch’s Unfermented Wine” for his church.
Words worth knowing
From the Hebrew and Greek.
“I have eagerly desired” (Luke 22:15). Literally “with desire I have desired,” a doubled phrase that makes it strong.
Passover. In Exodus 12 God passes over, sparing the homes marked by the blood.
A blessing. Jewish meal blessings praise God as the giver of the food.
To give thanks. Jesus “gave thanks” over the cup and the bread (Luke 22:17, 19). It’s where the word Eucharist comes from.
Remembrance. “Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19; 1 Corinthians 11:24–25). Christians understand this word differently, so no one word settles the debate.
Sharing or participation. Paul uses it for the cup and the bread in 1 Corinthians 10:16. It’s where we get “communion.”
Why so different?
Wafers or bread, wine or juice, kneeling or sitting. Here’s where the differences came from.
Wafer or loaf?
Custom, convenience, and different ideas about using unleavened bread like Passover.
Wine or grape juice?
The Bible’s meals used wine. In the 1800s the temperance movement led many Protestant churches to switch to juice.
One cup or many?
A shared cup pictures unity. Individual cups came in for health reasons around 1900.
Weekly or monthly?
Churches read the New Testament pattern differently. Some follow Acts 20:7 weekly; others keep it less often to keep it special.
Who may take it?
Churches differ on whether you must be baptized, a member or in doctrinal agreement (open, close and closed communion).
Kneel or sit?
Reverence, local custom and how the building is set up.
Good questions
Was the Last Supper a Passover Seder like the ones today?
Not exactly. Matthew, Mark and Luke call it a Passover meal. But the full Seder order with four cups is described in writings from about AD 200, so we can’t assume every part was used in Jesus’ day. John’s timeline also reads differently, and scholars still discuss why.
Did Jesus use the “third cup” of the Seder?
Some people teach that, but it can’t be proven. Luke mentions a cup before the bread (v. 17) and the cup “after the supper” (v. 20).
Does “remembrance” mean just thinking about it?
Remembering is the point, and it’s more than a private thought. Paul says taking it together also shows our unity (1 Corinthians 10:16–17) and proclaims Jesus’ death until He comes (1 Corinthians 11:26).
Do all Christians believe the bread and cup are only symbols?
No. That’s why this page shows four views. At Capitol City we hold the memorial view: the bread and cup represent Christ’s body and blood.
If a church believes Christ is truly present, does it think He is sacrificed again?
Catholic teaching says no: the Mass makes present the one sacrifice of the cross. We believe His sacrifice was once for all (Hebrews 10:10), and nothing is re-offered at the table. It’s fair to describe each view on its own terms.
Why does Luke mention two cups?
Luke has a cup before the bread (v. 17) and another “after the supper” (v. 20). A festive meal had more than one cup. A few early manuscripts leave out verses 19b–20, but most modern Bibles keep them, and the NIV includes a footnote.
What does “examine yourself” mean?
Read 1 Corinthians 11:27–32. Paul was correcting a church where some ate and drank while others went hungry. Examining yourself means coming honest, and coming in love for the people around you.
7 days of reading
Check off each day. Your phone remembers.
Sources
- Bible: Exodus 12–13; Exodus 24:3–8; Numbers 9; Deuteronomy 16; Joshua 5; 2 Chronicles 30, 35; Jeremiah 31; Matthew 26; Mark 14; Luke 22; John 13; Acts 2, 20; 1 Corinthians 5, 10–11; Hebrews 10; Revelation 19 (NIV).
- Early writings: Didache 9–10; Ignatius, Letter to the Smyrnaeans 7; Justin Martyr, First Apology 65–67; Mishnah, Pesachim 10. Free full texts of the church fathers: ccel.org.
- Church statements: Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1322–1419; Augsburg Confession X; Westminster Confession 29; Heidelberg Catechism 75–82; Thirty-Nine Articles XXVIII; UMC “This Holy Mystery”; Baptist Faith and Message (2000) VII.
- For further reading: Darrell Bock, Luke (BECNT); Joel Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT); I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC); Bruce Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament; Craig Blomberg, Jesus and the Gospels; Gordon Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians; Paul Bradshaw and Maxwell Johnson, The Eucharistic Liturgies.